Children’s Affective Experiences During Recess: Who Changes the Most Across a School Year?

  • Journal of Research in Childhood Education
  • May 31, 2025

William V. Massey, Nazlı Özkoca, James Arnold, Danielle Belcher & Megan B. Stellino

Abstract
The objective of this study was to investigate changes in elementary school students’ affective states during recess throughout a school year, and examine distinct subgroups variations by gender, grade level, race/ethnicity, and beginning of the school year scores. Participants included 1,022 students across nine schools within a large metropolitan area in the United States, who received services from a national nonprofit organization focused on improving recess quality. A shortened version of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule was used at four timepoints. Analyses used latent growth curve models that were computed using a maximum likelihood estimator with robust standard errors. Changes in positive affect and negative affect at recess for the entire sample were observed. Across sub-groups, the largest gains were for students who reported low levels of positive affect and high levels of negative affect at the beginning of the school year.

Source

Journal of Research in Childhood Education

Findings from the current study suggest the need to move beyond aggregating all scores within recess interventions, and, rather, toward targeting particular student sub-groups with both intervention strategies and analytical approaches.

Conclusion

School recess continues to be a meaningful and relevant area of interest as this context pertains to children’s holistic development. While a plethora of research findings suggest that recess confers social and emotional benefits for children, confirmation of these findings has remained elusive in more rigorous investigations. Findings from the current study suggest the need to move beyond aggregating all scores within recess interventions and toward the targeting of specific student sub-groups of need with both intervention strategies and analytical approaches. Data in the current study show a likely ceiling effect for recess interventions on affective states during recess in the general population; however, significant areas of growth for children who struggle at the beginning of the year were evidenced. The changes occurred in the context of overall improvements at recess, facilitated by a Playworks coach who facilitated organized and inclusive games, in addition to the regularly occurring free play activity during recess. Moreover, the results from the present study point to the need for future research to examine the experiences of children who do not identify within a gender binary at recess, as data indicated this may be a marginalized group on the playground.

Related Studies


April 17, 2024

An Evaluation of the Playworks Relay Program in Aurora Public Schools ›

Researchers have established evidence that recess provides cognitive and academic benefits, social and emotional benefits, and physical benefits to children during the school day. Over the past two decades, Playworks…

May 11, 2018

Evidence-based Strategies for a Beneficial School Recess ›

Based on the evidence obtained from the authors’ investigation with Playworks participants and coaches, five strategies were identified for health and physical education practitioners to consider in the implementation of…

November 8, 2022

Holistic Student Assessment (HSA) Retrospective Self-Change (RSC) survey ›

Between Fall 2021 and Spring 2022, Playworks collaborated with Partnerships in Education and Resilience (PEAR) to collect data across 8 regions involving 710 4th and 5th graders in schools offering…